
I'm gonna start this post by saying it wasn't my original idea to write this (hat tip to MLR, I think... although jury is still out b/c this is a weird topic in general), but the more I thought about it on the tail end of my & ARod's car ride back from VT yesterday, and then the subsequent trip back to NYC later in the evening, I think MLR might be onto something with his question posed to me yesterday:
"This might be insulting, but do you listen to Taylor Swift? I think it'd be interesting to get your take (older / wiser woman, from the south / likes music of all kinds) and how you feel about Taylor Swift "playing young" as I like to call it. A lot of female teen pop stars are trying to make themselves come off older (britney spears, et al), but she's content with marketing herself as a high schooler basically. & her not "upselling" her age"?
No, I'm not insulted, and yes, I do on occasion listen to her music. The 411 on Taylor Swift is here, but the short & sweet of her success is apparent with the fact that she has taken over the airwaves recently. On the surface, she seems to fit the mold of the pop-starlet image. Although us true country fans think she is a bit too "pop" to fit the genre, she has done good for our group's popularity despite our complaints that she (Kenny Chesney, Toby Keith, and some others) have taken country music away from its roots a bit too much... alas, I digress.
So what's the deal- is she under selling her age or is she actually a girl who makes money by selling sex appeal to high schoolers just like the rest of 'em?
What Taylor has going for her in the "pop" category: cute, blond, has that young & innocent vibe to her music, gender-ambiguous name, she came from the Disney manufacturing plant and dated another famous teen-singer, a Jonas brother in fact! She's invited to all the music parties, her last concert sold out NYC's Madison Square Garden & was 90% full of girls under the age of 18- all in all? Yes, she's a total pop star.
What Taylor has going for her in the "country" category: cute, plays acoustic guitar and sings, writes music about relationships gone bad and the revenge she's gonna take on her ex-boyfriends in an un-PC way (burning pictures, dating his best friends, telling everyone he's "gay". etc), wears cowboy boots with a dress in public (my favorite guilty pleasure) and loves her Mama.
Does she, like her predecessors (Madonna, Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera) sell sex to get ahead? On the surface, no- she's sugar spice & everything nice... But in researching/listening to her songs, they're all about the same thing: boys and getting with the one she wants.
Britney's "I'm a Slave for You" and Christina's "Ain't No Other Man" are just about the same as "You Belong With Me" - she's totally obsessed with this guy and that he's not paying any attention to her. Different wording but same message: Listen up- I like you... now let's get it on!!! Madonna did her fare share of sex appeal, but also did some sappy songs- like Taylor's "That's the Way I Loved You" Madonna's "Take A Bow" and "Something to Remember" all speak to a love they had, it's over and yet it still influences their lives.
In sorting through all these blond ladies' hits, it's all about the same thing: boys and love, and how both went wrong or right. While the prior ladies appeal(ed) to the older 20's + "dirty dancing in the club" scene, Taylor gives angsty teenage girls everywhere something to listen to and identify with.
In the end, MLR's an age-inappropriate* crush on Taylor Swift (circa his Leighton Meister quality ogling potential) isn't all that off base- people like Taylor because she sings to stuff they can relate to and appears to have a good time doing it. She's selling the PG version of the usual rated R "sex appeal" music on the radio now a days. No under or up selling her age- but actually being right on target. At 14-18, girls shouldn't be getting down and dirty with boys. Maybe I was a little innocent back in my high school days, but her songs seem right on track with what was going on in high school for me and my girlfriends. Britney, Christina & Madonna- not so much. Even in college, I thought their songs were a little bit risque to be on the radio & out in public air waves.
Still skeptical how I related to Miss Swift today, I kept searching... Country roots be damned- this video made me totally feel like I'm one with Taylor Swift- JOTW nominee perhaps?
Every good Southern girl knows that all men, even thugs, xo the homemade caramel delights!
*FYI- she's 20 now, so ogle away boys of AMDAL without feeling like dirty old men.